Saturday, November 21, 2026

Decidedly Different Soda Lakes

Soda Lakes near Ragtown, Nevada (Plate XVI, Russell 1885).
As readers who have been following my current geotripping series know, Israel Cook Russell was the young geologist with the US Geological Survey who studied Lake Lahontan—an immense body of water that covered much of northwest Nevada just 13,000 years ago. In the early 1880s, he spent three field seasons criss-crossing its basin, now a harsh and exceedingly dry land.
“The mountains are rugged and angular, usually unclothed by vegetation. The valleys, even more dreary than the mountains ... form a picture of desolation and solitude. It is in this inhospitable region, now so arid that many a lost traveler has perished from thirst, that the great lake existed in recent geological time, which has been made a subject of study by the writer and his associates” (all quotes are Russell’s unless noted).

Lahontan Basin—a picture of desolation and solitude.

Russell and his associates surveyed mountain ranges and basins, measured heights of old shorelines, sketched relic gravel bars and spits, described sediments deposited on the lake bottom, collected rocks, fossils and tufa (calcareous deposits formed underwater), and much more. They found Lake Lahontan to be highly irregular, as much as 886 feet deep, and about 8,422 square miles in area. Throughout its life, it had no outlet.

Just a few years later, Russell’s monumental Geological History of Lake Lahontan (USGS Monograph 11) was published. It measures 9 × 12 inches, weighs 3 pounds 14 ounces, and contains 302 pages of text and figures, as well as 46 plates including 19 maps.

Small excerpt from Lake Lahontan pocket map (Plate XLVI). Lahontan is darker blue (greenish blue to my eye), today’s lakes are pale blue. Added arrow marks Soda Ponds near Ragtown.
As the map above shows, they also surveyed existing lakes, nine in all. Seven were playa lakes, which occupied shallow depressions with no outlet. Their size varied with the season and from year to year. “… not uncommonly [the lake] becomes completely desiccated, especially in dry years.”

Winnemucca Lake, “completely desiccated” (September 2025).
In the Monograph, several playa lakes were described in detail and illustrated. The maps were black and white, and topography was shown with hachures—short parallel lines (density and angle indicate slope). Hachures were considered a natural way to represent mountains, and hachured maps were said to be easy to read. But they lacked precision (1). 
Walker Lake (Plate XV). Click image to view hachures.
Also on Russell’s list of lakes to survey were the Soda Ponds near Ragtown (2). “… these are of a decidedly different character from those [playa lakes] enumerated above, and will receive special attention”, he explained.
Soda Ponds near Ragtown (now Soda Lakes near Fallon).
They found Little Soda Lake to be greatly altered by soda (trona) mining, and gave it only limited attention:

“The smaller lake, when the accompanying map was made, had been so changed by excavation and the construction of evaporating vats that its original form had been destroyed. Its surface is 20 feet higher than the larger lake, and 65 feet below the general desert surface.”

In contrast, Big Soda Lake was very much worthy of study, and fascinating in its form. It sits in a deep depression in a low cone, and though 268.5 acres in area, is largely out of view. The “inner slope [of the depression] is abrupt and at times approaches the perpendicular.” The rim reached as high as 165 feet above the lake surface (in Russell’s time), but only about 80 feet above the surrounding desert. Furthermore, “the outer slope of the cone is gentle and merges almost imperceptibly with the desert surface …” (italics mine; I missed both the cone and the lake on my first try).

Where’s the lake? Hopefully this is its gentle outer slope.
Yes! There it is, surrounded by steep inner walls.
To make Big Sodas Lake's striking form more clear, Russell provided a cross-section. “The form of the larger depression is still farther illustrated by the cross-section given at the bottom of the plate [XVI], which has been constructed from actual measurements with an engineer’s level and a sounding line.”

Center third of Big Soda Lake cross-section; only tops of long gentle slopes included here.
Russell’s mention of “sounding line” refers to their survey of the lake bottom, using lead-and-line sounding. A lead (pronounced “led” and usually made of lead) was tied to the end of a line marked at regular intervals. The cup-shaped bottom of the lead was packed with animal fat (or something equally sticky) and dropped overboard. When it hit bottom, depth was read on the marked line at the surface. After retrieving a sample and recording its composition (typically “fine tenacious black mud having a strong odor of sulphuretted hydrogen”), they paddled to the next point. Meanwhile, surveyors onshore noted the boat’s position for each sounding (3).
Big Soda Lake (from Plate XVI). Numbers on lake are depths, each one a sounding.
It was in the Soda Lakes map that I found Russell's “special attention” most obvious. Unlike the maps for playa lakes, it was printed in color: brown for topography, black for cultural features and blue for water. Notably, topography is shown with contour lines instead of the more familiar hachures. But there was little choice, as we see if we look closely at Russell’s map.

The legend (at the bottom of the page) states “Contours 20 feet apart.” In other words, adjacent lines represent a change of 20 vertical feet on the ground. With this in mind, note the dramatic change in spacing—where tight parallel lines surrounding the water give way to lines much farther apart. This is the transition from steep inner walls to very gentle outer slopes. Hachures were not capable of this kind of precision and clarity.

Of great interest to Russell was the composition of the cones, which might reveal how these curious lakes formed. So the crew carefully measured, sketched and sampled the inner walls of Big Soda Lake. Mostly they found ejecta—fine lapilli and fragments of basalt as large as three feet across. The Soda Lake cones were volcanic!
Smoking guns: lapilli (mixed with sand) ...
... and “bombs” (basalt fragments).
To Russell, the larger story was clear. “The form of the cones and the nature of the material of which they are composed leave no doubt that these are crater-rings, i.e., low cones of eruption containing large craters.” But obvious stratification of the material suggested a complicated history rather than a single eruption.

Especially intriguing were layers of apparent lake sediments—marl and clay containing fresh-water shells and tufa. “From the presence of fossiliferous lacustral [lakebed] clays, it seems evident that volcanic eruption was interrupted by periods during which the lake covered the craters.” The tufa “proved” that Lake Lahontan was present during at least some of the eruptions.

But Russell may have been wrong.
When I visited Big Soda Lake, I had with me A Tour of Geology from Soda Lakes to Stillwater Marsh, Nevada (dePolo et al. 2018). The section about the lakes explains that they are maars, “formed when basalt magma rose close to the surface, boiled the groundwater, and caused an intensely explosive eruption … ”. I prefer geology.com's description:
“A maar is a volcanic crater that forms when magma contacts groundwater to produce a steam explosion. … The crater floor of a maar is usually below the original ground surface. After the eruption, an inflow of groundwater often turns the crater into a shallow lake.”
That fits with what Russell described and I saw at Big Soda Lake. However, dePolo et al. disagree with regard to timing, concluding that the volcanoes must have been “younger than the sediments that were deposited in the youngest version of Lake Lahontan.” Why? Because there are no relic shoreline terraces on the Big Soda Lake cone (4).
In the Lahontan Basin, relic terraces are”the most common of the records inscribed”; BLM photo.
But wait! According to Russell, the crater rim at its highest is just 80 feet above the surrounding desert (dePolo et al. say 72 feet). Furthermore, the slopes in between are long and gentle. Were they suitable for terrace development? Russell thought not: “terraces consist of a sloping terrace and a sea-cliff above ... but sea-cliffs are seldom formed when the slope of the beach [site of wave action] is very gentle.” For more, see pages 88 and 100 in his Monograph.

I have another question. If the Soda Lakes volcanoes erupted after Lake Lahontan was gone, what explains the occasional layers of lakebed sediments that Russell found exposed on the inner walls? Oddly, dePolo et al. make no mention of them—perhaps because the walls have been largely submerged for more than a century!

In 1902, Congress passed the Newlands Reclamation Act to encourage agriculture in drier parts of the American West. The first project was in Nevada, home of Congressman Francis Newlands (hmm, is there a connection?). Canals were built, rivers diverted, and the Carson River dammed not far from the Soda Lakes, creating today’s Lahontan Reservoir (more here). Parts of the southern Lahontan Basin are no longer arid in the extreme, covered now in lush green irrigated fields. 
Soda Lakes (upper left) and agricultural fields near Fallon; Google Earth 2026.
With extensive irrigation, the water table rose 60 feet, as did the surface of Big Soda Lake (source), flooding the steep inner walls that Russell studied. But that didn’t keep Roger Morrison from including Russell’s findings, as well as his own, in his discussion of Soda Lakes eruptions. Like Russell, he interpreted them as contemporaneous with Lake Lahontan, at least in part (1964; see also Note 5 below).

As for me ... I would like to think Russell was right, for in my travels I’ve come to really like him! He was passionate about his work and clear in his writing. But I’m most taken by his ability to find “charm” in landscapes “desolate in the extreme”. So I will end the Lahontan series with some of his more evocative words:
“In crossing these wastes the traveler may ride for many miles over a perfectly level floor, with an unbroken sky-line before him, and not an object in sight to cast a shadow on the ocean-like expanse. Mirages may be seen every day on these heat deserts. Similar optical illusions give strange fanciful forms to the mountains, and sometimes transfigure them beyond all recognition. At such times a pack-train crossing the desert a few miles distant frequently appears like some strange caravan of grotesque beasts fording a shallow lake, the shores of which advance as one rides away. The monotony of midday on the desert is thus broken by delusive forms that are ever changing, and suggest a thousand fancies which divert the attention from the fatigues of the journey.”

What is that strange caravan fording Lake Winnemucca?! 

Notes

(1) For more about hachures vs. contour lines, see Mapping Lake Lahontan with contour lines and color. Hachures, contour lines and shaded relief, sometimes in combination, were all used in maps in Monograph XI.

(2) Ragtown was named for the tattered clothing that immigrants hung on bushes to dry, after washing it in the Carson River. The river was the first potable water after crossing the Forty-mile Desert (today’s Humboldt and Carson playa lakes). Mark Twain called it “the Great American Desert—forty memorable miles of bottomless sand, into which the coach wheels sunk from six inches to a foot. ... It was a dreary pull and a long and thirsty one, for we had no water.”

(3) Russell describes taking soundings in detail only for Pyramid Lake. I’m assuming the same procedure was used at Big Soda Lake, as he doesn’t say otherwise.

(4) Other sources (online) also state that the Soda Lakes volcanoes erupted too recently to have overlapped with Lake Lahontan. But none that I found include evidence.

(5) Roger Morrison surveyed the southern part of Lake Lahontan in the late 1940s. At Big Soda Lake, he could examine only a small part of what Russell saw, so in his 1964 report he included Russell’s descriptions of the now-submerged walls. Based on these descriptions, Morrison agreed that the layers with fossils and tufa probably were lacustrine (lakebeds). He himself found lacustrine sediments in the uppermost walls, above the lake surface. Morrison’s interpretation, like Russell’s, placed at least some of the eruptions during Lake Lahontan time.

Sources

David Rumsey Historical Map Collection. Plate XVI: Soda Lakes near Ragtown, Nevada. Accessed November 2026. The Rumsey Collection is a wonderful resource, with high resolution images free to download and many rabbit holes to explore.

dePolo, CM, et al. 2018. Sparkling or still? A tour of geology from Soda Lakes to Stillwater Marsh, Nevada (Guide for the Earth Science Week Field Trip). Nevada Bureau of Mines and Geology Educational Series 63, 25 p.

Morrison, RB. 1964. Lake Lahontan: geology of southern Carson Desert, Nevada. USGS Prof. Paper 401. PDF.

Russell, IC. 1885. Geological history of Lake Lahontan. USGS Monograph 11, PDF; (for Plate XLVI pocket map, see PDF).

Sunday, November 1, 2026

The Monthly Orchid: the Frog

See any frogs? (MWI)
Welcome back to The Monthly Orchid, a series about native orchids of South Dakota. This episode features Dactylorhiza viridis, the Frog Orchid, one of the most widespread orchids in the world. It occurs across Eurasia and Canada, and in the United States from Alaska to North Carolina. But it's new to me. Here's a chance to get to know it before I search for it in the wild.

In South Dakota, the Frog Orchid appears to be limited to the Black Hills and Harding County (northwest corner of the state). But not all that far away, in central Minnesota, it is said to be widespread and “most prevalent in upland hardwood forest along the tension zone between the western prairie and eastern forest”. This is yet another species that makes me wonder: With more thorough botanizing, will it be discovered in hardwood forests in far eastern South Dakota?

Frog Orchid in Minnesota (MWI).

In South Dakota, Dactylorhiza viridis has been found mainly in forested areas, occasionally in mountain meadows. Go Orchids reports that in North America “it prefers moist habitats, growing in wet coniferous forests, tundras, prairies, meadows, and bogs.” So I was surprised to read that in the UK and Europe, it’s commonly found in grasslands.

Frog Orchid in grassland; Beddingham Hill, England (Keith DP Wilson).

In his 1938 Wildflowers in Britain, the honorable R. Gathorne-Hardy wrote of the “squat green-flowered frog orchid”, which he considered “grotesque” (Fay et al. 2015). Gathorne-Hardy may have been a highly respected botanist, but I have to disagree. While it’s true that the Frog Orchid is a bit on the stout side, “squat” is inappropriate. Perhaps he knew it only from grasslands in the UK (photo above). On more favorable sites, plants can be tall and graceful.

A Frog Orchid amid greenery on a hospitable site in Finland (Kari Pihlaviita).
Dactylorhiza viridis, also known as Coeloglosum viride (1), used to be included in the genus Platanthera, of which we have six species in South Dakota. These are our bog or rein orchids. Not surprisingly, they are similar to the Frog Orchid—slender green plants with inconspicuous green to white flowers, and flowers with a spurred lip petal (labellum). Even so, the Frog Orchid usually can be easily distinguished by several features, especially in combination—leaves, inflorescences, lip petals and tubers.

Leaves are alternate on stems (vs. all basal in some Platanthera species).

Frog Orchid leaves clasp the stem or nearly so (MWI).
Inflorescences often (but not always) have long leaflike bracts subtending the flowers, hence “Long-bracted Orchid”—another of its common names.
Dactylorhiza viridis in Cumbria, England; note prominent bracts in inflorescence (naturalhistoryman).
The lip or labellum (lowermost of an orchid flower’s six petals) has a small saccate (bladder-like) spur at the base, and is 3-lobed at the tip. The middle lobe is much smaller than outer ones and sometimes said to be tooth-like.
Dactylorhiza viridis; upper arrows point to globular spurs, lower to 3-lobed tips of lip petals (note tiny central lobe at arrow tip). Photo ©Al Schneider, http://www.swcoloradowildflowers.com.
One more distinguishing feature—Frog Orchids have palmate tubers as the next image shows. But I am NOT recommending you dig up a plant to check! Tubers are mentioned mainly to explain the genus name: Dactylorhiza (Latin) means “finger root”. Finger number ranges from 2 to 5.
Platanthera viridis; Berlin, R. Friedländer & sohn, 1904. Biodiversity Heritage Library.
But wait! Surely the most reliable feature for confident id is the eponymous frog …
MWI (labels mine).
... wrong!!!

Much searching and consultation revealed that whether the Frog Orchid looks anything like a frog is a matter of debate. Some orchid enthusiasts see suggestions of frogs in the flowers. For example, the Wild Flower Finder sees a frog’s head in the hood formed by the upper tepals—“think Kermit the Frog.” Add the two longer lobes at the tip of the lip petal, and maybe it's a leaping frog!

However, others find nothing frog-like about the Frog Orchid. In The Wild Orchids of Britain (1950), Jocelyn Brooke is emphatic on this point:

“one must enlist the eye of faith to detect any batrachian quality in this orchid. Apart from the fact that it is small and green, there seems to the ordinary observer nothing frog-like about it. …. To say the least, the name is of no assistance as a means of identification.”

To be honest, I DO see leaping frogs, for example in the photo below. And you? See any frogs? Feel free to explain in Comments.

Frog Orchid in Sussex, England; reddish to maroon tepals are fairly common (Keith DP Wilson).

Note

(1) Frog Orchid has a long history of synonymy, listed here chronologically (from Fay et al. 2015). Linnaeus was the first to assign a binomial—Satyrium viride in 1753 (any ideas as to why he chose "Satyr"?). This was followed by Orchis viridis, 1769; Habenaria viridis, 1813; Gymnadenia viridis, 1817; Sieberia viridis, 1817; Coeloglossum viride, 1820; Entaticus viridis, 1821; Chamorchis viridis, 1827); Platanthera viridis, 1829; Himantoglossum viride, 1830; Peristylus viridis, 1835; and finally, Dactylorhiza viridis, 1997.

Dactylorhiza viridis and Coeloglossum viride are both used currently; Platanthera viridis persists in older sources.

Sources

Brooke, J. & Bone, G. (1950). The Wild Orchids of Britain. Bodley Head, London.

Fay, M.F., Sayers, B. & Taylor, I. 2015. 802. Dactylorhiza viridis. Curtis's Botanical Magazine, 32: 33-41.

Flora of North America. Coeloglossum viride. Accessed October 2026.

Go Orchids. Dactylorhiza viridis. Accessed October 2026.

Southwest Colorado Wildflowers. Dactylorhiza viridis. Accessed October 2026.

Minnesota Wildflower Information. Coeloglossum viride. Accessed October 2026.