Sunday, February 8, 2015

Of Anchor Ice & Cottonwood Flowers

It was the first of February, 8:30 AM, and 17º F after a cloudy night with light snow.  When I reached the river, I saw two men with poles standing in the water as ice floated by.  What were they doing?!  Fishing? hunting crawdads? collecting garbage? maybe playing ice golf, an ancient Scandinavian sport?
Will this be the final putt?
The men intently studied the river as my lanceleaf cottonwood tree stood by.
This month’s tree-following post was to be about my search for a new tree, but the cottonwood I've followed for a year now led me to two unexpected and interesting things. First there were the men who were taking photos of ice on the river bed.
They used a GoPro action camera – the kind folks wear to record adrenalin-inducing activities.
Ice on the river bed?  How can that be?  Ice floats, being less dense than water.  True ... but as I now know, under the right conditions a special kind of ice forms – anchor ice.  It’s really interesting and worth keeping an eye out for.  I’m glad I asked those guys what they were doing.

Cold nights are best, well below freezing.  Where the river is fast-moving and shallow, water may become super-cooled and stay liquid below its normal freezing temperature.  The sand, gravel, rocks, etc. that it’s flowing over also cool to that temperature.  The water is moving right along so surface ice doesn't form, but floating crystals (frazil) freeze out.  They stick to material on the river bed and to each other, making gray-green soft slushy ice.  When the day begins to warm, anchor ice begins to break free and float downstream.  Soon it’s all gone.  [Here’s a summary with clear explanations, and another in PDF format.]




Top: gravel and small rocks on bottom of anchor ice removed from river bed

Middle: anchor ice anchored to river bed

Bottom: anchor ice breaking free from river bed 

(modified from Kempema et al. 2008; click on image to see more detail)


Gray-green detached anchor ice floating downstream.
For years I’ve watched murky globs of ice float down the river on cold mornings.  I always thought they had broken off from ice along the river margins.  Now I know better.  The things you learn when you follow a tree!
video

Anchor ice was pretty minimal that day and has been for most of this unusually-mild winter.  But it can be dramatic with significant impacts, like creating dams and scouring river beds.  “Seeing is believing” so have a look at this anchor ice video – a “nature treat for the day” from the northeast USA.

--- ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ✿ ---

The second thing of interest is actually quite amazing ... my tree is blooming in February!
Cottonwood in full bloom; click on image to see fringed bracts, young ovaries and stigmas as in diagram below.

Suspicious?  You should be.  It is blooming ... but in my kitchen.
Last month when I was wondering if my cottonwood was the bitter kind, I collected twigs with buds to examine at home.  The true bitter cottonwood, the narrowleaf, has very resinous buds, but those on my tree aren’t – this suggests it's a hybrid.  When I was done, I put the twigs in a small container with water to see if maybe something interesting would happened.

Something did.  Now there are two female catkins (flower clusters), other buds have tiny bits of green at the tips – leaves? – and little twigs have grown roots!  Of course now I will put them in a pot.  Maybe something interesting will happen ...
I’m not surprised to find flowers out of season and roots growing from tiny twigs.  Cottonwoods are notoriously opportunistic.  They produce prodigious amounts of cottony seeds and cast them to the wind.  Maybe – just maybe – one  will land in a suitable place and grow.  Some species sucker and spread readily, as does mine.  Fallen live branches can root and grow.  And they grow fast.  My tree may look majestic, with all the noble characteristics we associate with trees – strength, great stature, longevity, steadfastness.  But it’s really more like a scrappy nine-lived alley-cat, resigned to (and ignoring) the capricious hand of fate.  Try anything and everything ... be ready ... live fast and die young ... wotthehell, wotthehell
Mehitabel (by Don Marquis).


More about anchor ice in the Laramie River:

Kempema, E, Ettema, R, and McGee, B.  2008.  Insights from anchor ice formation in the Laramie River, Wyoming.  19th IAHR International Symposium on Ice.

Kempema, E, and Ettema, R.  2010.  Anchor ice rafting:  observations from the Laramie River.  River Research and Applications 27:1126-1135.

14 comments:

  1. Fascinating stuff ... as always. I was starting to think, "Really, your Cottonwood is blooming in February?" and then you showed us and explained why. ;-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, PP. Actually I was quite surprised to find the catkins ... I figured the cottonwood would be programmed to avoid blooming in winter ... wrong.

      Delete
  2. What a pretty bloom. Lucky you! Charlie looks like he's enjoying watching over the bud! Thanks for sharing.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Anna. What a surprise it was to find those buds opening! I guess there's enough light and warmth in the kitchen.

      Delete
  3. Amazing what there is to learn -- anchor ice. Never heard of it before but now I know. Thanks, Hollis.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. it's neat what I've learned by participating in this group!

      Delete
  4. A fascinating tale of the Cottonwood and the anchor ice! Loved seeing the Cottonwood flowers. I thought you might be interested, Hollis, to see my ice forms prose poem, 'Chattermarks', in this eBook, which resulted from a Poetry School course at the Polar Museum, Cambridge University ...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's neat, Caroline. I also took a quick look at your poetry website - haven't figured out where the poems are, but I will. I'm caught up with taxes right now, facing a deadline :-( More later.

      Delete
  5. as I said before - so much to learn about other than trees -and as well as trees- in your TF posts. The P. Nigra version of Cottonwoods are hard to grow from seed - a bit particular about their germinating conditions - all fluff and no flounder. Maybe the vegetative route is the most opportunistic! p.s. Charlie is looking suspiciously - "In the end, everything is a gag"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, ttt. I agree ... I now see cottonwoods as very much into vegetative reproduction! As for Charlie's philosophy ... have to say, sometimes I agree on that too ;-)

      Delete
  6. Hello! You just left a lovely comment on my tree following but I accidently deleted IT insted if publishing it! So sorry, but thank you for the comment! X

    ReplyDelete
  7. The non-sticky bud picture is beautiful. And like the others - the idea of anchor ice is a new one. I too would have thought any ice floating along the surface has simply broken away from somewhere on top of the water. Why were the men photographing the ice?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Lucy -- you again picked out the photo taken with my macro lens. Using it more is a 2015 resolution. Those guys were from the University's Civil Engineering department, looking at sediment transport by ice, and impact on the river channel. That's all I know ... we didn't talk long. It was cold and they obviously weren't comfortable in the icy water.

      Delete
  8. I love your blog posts - you always tell me something I didn't know!
    Anchor ice is a great concept and I'm still enjoying your cottonwood tales.
    All the best :)

    ReplyDelete